Subcontracting: The Risky Business

architecture-1727807_1280

Subcontracting is a common practice in modern businesses, but many do not realise that it’s putting their business at risk.

Companies hire out elements of the service to reduce costs, scale and descale workforces with ease and create space in-house for priority tasks. However, in doing so, they compromise the ability to manage quality control measures and timelines, which can be detrimental to the business and reputation. This is not to say that every subcontracting arrangement is bad, but there are definite risks associated with subcontracting and using other companies that heavily subcontract their work.

The Benefits of Subcontracting

There are clear incentives for subcontracting; let’s break them down.

  • Access to Specialists – Subcontracting can make specialists accessible to businesses on an as-and-when-needed basis. It can be expensive to always keep a specialist on salary, so this option is appealing to many companies.
  • Control over Workforce Scale – Subcontracting is one of the easiest ways to scale and downscale workforces quickly. This is useful for seasonal businesses, and it prevents them from having to maintain a large and expensive workforce throughout the entire year.
  • Focus on Core Business – Many choose to subcontract service elements, so the in-house workforce has more time for core jobs.
  • Temporary Cover – Sometimes, businesses need last-minute or temporary cover, and subcontracting can be a quick and convenient fix.
  • Cutting Costs – Freelancers usually charge higher rates; however, the ability to use them on a project-by-project basis can save businesses money across the entire year.

The Risks of Subcontracting

It’s safe to say that subcontracting is a convenient option for many businesses; however, this convenience comes at a cost.

Adherence to Quality Control Measures

One of the distinct advantages of an in-house task force over a subcontracted one is quality. When work is handled externally, it can be very difficult to maintain consistent quality standards.

In-house employees can be trained to follow strict procedures and quality-control measures that ensure products and projects are up to scratch. When businesses subcontract, it is nearly impossible to know whether these measures are being adhered to. Corners may be cut to the detriment of the project.

There will be exceptions, particularly for businesses with long-standing relationships. However, these risks, especially with new partnerships, often cause genuine issues for reputations.

Experience

Though subcontracting can be a convenient way to scale workforces, the lack of experience can cause issues. Granted, there are times when the contractor is a specialist in their field, but many are generalists, playing the jack of all trades. They might be able to get the job done, but it’s unlikely they will have the same skill and knowledge as an in-house team member.

Internal teams can develop long-term experience with a specific company, which can help them perform at a high standard and align with the company culture and guidelines. This experience is vital for crisis management and navigating complex projects in specialist trades.

Communication Barriers

One of the greatest issues with subcontracting is the breakdown of communication. Typically, one company hires another to do a job, which will in turn pass the work on to another company, and so on down a chain. By the time someone is actually completing the job, the initial message and requirements have been utterly diluted. The company commissioning the work is so rarely informed about the extent of these contracting chains, leaving them completely out of the loop and dissatisfied with the final result.

Overreliance

Overdependence on subcontractors can raise unexpected problems for businesses. If contractors are overrun with other work or simply do not want to take your project, they don’t have to! This can leave businesses in a difficult situation where they cannot uphold their commitments.

A Case Study

Subcontracting has been a popular topic of discussion in the exhibition industry. Business shows are seasonal, with most taking place from January to June and September to November. This creates challenges for businesses to maintain peak-season headcounts year-round, and so subcontracting is very common. The practice has raised concerns as exhibition stand design is a specialism, which balances graphic design and technical CAD design with project management and installation.  Many in the industry feel that subcontracting is not only risky but also irresponsible.

Across their 25 years in business, one exhibition stand contractor, Quadrant2Design, has witnessed firsthand the repercussions of the all-too-common subcontracting. Issues include complications and delays, stands that look nothing like their promised design, projects that have been lost in transit, poorly installed, or not installed at all.

James Vicefield, the Head of Marketing and Sales at Quadrant2Design, shared:

“In the exhibition industry, there is an epidemic of subcontracting. With brand reputations at stake, we cannot get behind these practices. All of our departments work in the same building, in person, at our facility in Poole, and we never subcontract our work to third parties. We believe that our brilliant reviews and feedback are a testament to the success of this business model.”

To Subcontract or Not to Subcontract

While subcontracting may be a convenient solution, it comes with undeniable risks such as weakened communication, quality and skill sets. These can compromise the quality of projects and brand reputation. While subcontracting may offer cover as a tie-over when necessary, and can allow smaller businesses to gain access to specialists, it’s never going to be as reliable as an in-house team. It may have its place in the business world, but we certainly would not be basing business models around it.