February Health Strikes Raise Legal Issues For Companies – Warns Leading Employment Lawyer.

Pam Loch headshot_small

Employers in Sussex need to be aware of the legal and wellbeing issues raised by NHS strikes scheduled for next week and later this month, cautions leading employment lawyer and HR expert Pam Loch, Managing Director of Loch Law, part of the Loch Associates Group, based in Brighton, Tunbridge Wells and London.

Members of the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) will strike again on Monday 6 and Tuesday 7 February, with GMB-member ambulance workers joining them on 6 February, with an additional strike scheduled for Monday 20 February.

“There are people who are off work waiting for operations and essential treatment who can’t return to work until they have had their treatment, and their employers want them back. Additionally, colleagues juggling the workload of team members who are off due to ill health are under additional strain, especially with current recruitment challenges making it hard to backfill short-term positions, and this will be increased if their co-worker’s return to work is delayed further due to NHS strike action,” says Pam Loch.

“The problem is particularly acute for smaller companies, who tend to operate on leaner numbers of staff, so employees being off sick – especially long-term sick – is even more critical. Businesses that employ a lot of older staff, who are more reliant on the NHS, are also particularly at risk,” she explains.

Loch Law is cautioning businesses that they need to make sure they understand the legal implications of these challenges before acting.

“The law states that if you are going to dismiss someone because they are incapable of doing their work because of an illness or condition, if they have a disability then you have to make sure you don’t discriminate against them because of that disability by unfairly dismissing them because they are absent,” says Loch. “But there will be other people who are off work who don’t have a disability, such as if they have broken their leg; it’s not a disability, but they may still be off work for a long time.  You still have to follow a fair and reasonable process to dismiss them if they have more than 2 years’ service.

“I would expect that a tribunal would have little sympathy with an employer trying to dismiss someone because they are unable to return to work because they haven’t had the treatment they were expecting due to strike action when there is some likelihood that the treatment will take place in the near future.

“But if the employer is facing continual delays in the employee returning to work – which could happen with repeated industrial action – such a move may be more justified in the eyes of a Tribunal.”

Loch Law is also advising employers to think beyond their legal obligations to consider the health and wellbeing of all staff, both those on sick leave and colleagues who are managing their absence.

“Employers and HR teams have got to think about how they manage their existing teams to keep them on board and happy,” advises Loch. “Communication is important, keeping staff in the loop as best you can while protecting confidentiality. If a team is expecting a colleague to come back to work to help share the workload and this is not going to happen, bosses need to manage their expectations around this.

“Staff who are off on long-term sick leave may well feel pressure to get back to work, but it’s important not to put more pressure on them as it could cause them stress and anxiety too, so exacerbating the situation.”

Long-term sick leave being extended due to postponed treatment may also require firms to examine their sick pay. While there is no requirement to pay more than Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) to people who are off on long-term sick leave, many companies do for at least part of the absence. If an employee’s operation or treatment is postponed due to strike action, this may push their sick leave beyond the terms of Company Sick Pay. This then raises a question as to whether companies should extend their discretionary sick pay, as the return-to-work delay is beyond the control of the employee?

“There is no legal requirement for companies to do so, but it obviously would be a nice thing to do. However, it will depend on the financial position of the employer; many businesses won’t be able to extend discretionary sick pay, especially if they have had to backfill the position with a temp,” says Loch.